JC Decisions

1,473 decisions

No JurisdictionUnited Methodist Church

A Request from the Clergy Session of the New England Annual Conference for a Declaratory Decision

October 16, 2025 · Clergy Session of the New England Annual Conference

The Judicial Council refused to answer a question about ordination requirements because it didn't cite specific Book of Discipline paragraphs as required for declaratory decisions.

Key Holding

Requests for declaratory decisions must reference specific paragraphs of the Book of Discipline to establish proper jurisdiction.

¶335 · ¶416.6 · ¶326.3See also:
United Methodist Church

Request for Reconsideration of Judicial Council Decision 1517

August 07, 2025 · Not specified

The Judicial Council refused to reconsider its previous Decision 1517.

Key Holding

The request for reconsideration of Decision 1517 was denied.

See also:
United Methodist Church

IN RE: Request for a Declaratory Decision from the College of Bishops of the Southeastern Jurisdiction of the United Methodist Church Regarding the Meaning, Application and Effect of Paragraph 2549 of the 2016 Book of Discipline as it Relates to the Process of the Board of Trustees of the Mississippi Annual Conference Adopted on October 20, 2022

June 02, 2025 · College of Bishops of the Southeastern Jurisdiction

The Judicial Council ruled that Mississippi Annual Conference's attempt to create a church exit process using ¶2549 after ¶2553 expired was illegal and void.

Key Holding

Annual conference trustees cannot unilaterally create church disaffiliation processes outside of established disciplinary authority, and ¶2549 cannot be used as a substitute for the expired ¶2553 disaffiliation provision.

¶2549 · ¶2553
United Methodist Church

Review of a Bishop's Ruling on a Question asked at the Called Special Session of the Dakotas Conference Regarding the Cabinet Resolution to Close Embrace Church/UMC

April 25, 2025 · Delegate at Dakotas Annual Conference Special Session

The Judicial Council ruled that the Dakotas Annual Conference improperly used church closure procedures as a pretext to allow Embrace UMC to leave the denomination with its property, violating the Trust Clause.

Key Holding

Paragraph 2549 cannot be used for church separation under the pretext of 'closure' to bypass the Trust Clause and allow churches to leave with their property.

¶2549 · ¶2501 · ¶52 · ¶2609.6 · ¶244.1 · ¶246.1 · ¶252See also:
United Methodist Church

Request for a Declaratory Decision From the Arkansas Annual Conference Requesting Clarification of Decision 1503 As It Relates to Paragraphs 16.7 [sic 16.6], 340.2(a)(3)(a), and 2533 of the 2016 Book of Discipline as amended Clarifying the Relative Authority of a Local Church Pastor and a Local Church Board of Trustees in the Use of Church Property for Religious Services

April 25, 2025 · Arkansas Annual Conference

The Judicial Council clarified that pastors have sole discretion over performing marriage ceremonies and that local church trustees cannot prevent pastors from using church facilities for religious services, including same-sex marriage ceremonies.

Key Holding

Local church boards of trustees cannot prevent or interfere with a pastor's use of church property for religious services, including marriage ceremonies, as pastors have sole discretion over performing marriages under church law.

¶340.2(a)(3)(a) · ¶341.3 · ¶2533.1 · ¶2610.2(j) · ¶16.6 · ¶340.2(a)(3)See also:
UnconstitutionalUnited Methodist Church

IN RE: Petition for Declaratory Decision from the Postponed 2020 General Conference Regarding the Constitutionality, Meaning, Application, and Effect of Petition 20956 (¶101)

October 26, 2024 · General Conference delegate requesting declaratory decision

The General Conference unconstitutionally gave jurisdictional conferences the authority to adapt the Book of Discipline without first amending the Constitution, though other parts of the petition remain valid.

Key Holding

The General Conference exceeded its constitutional authority by extending adaptation rights to jurisdictional conferences through legislative action rather than constitutional amendment.

¶101 · ¶2610 · ¶31.5 · ¶27.5 · ¶59 · ¶60 · ¶61See also: , , , , , ,
United Methodist Church

IN RE: Review of a Decision of Law by Bishop Latrelle Easterling in the Peninsula-Delaware Annual Conference

October 26, 2024 · Elder requesting ruling of law in Peninsula-Delaware Annual Conference

The Judicial Council reviewed a bishop's legal ruling about clergy serving disaffiliated churches, reversing one ruling as improper but affirming another as correctly identifying a hypothetical question.

Key Holding

Questions of law must state a connection to specific conference action and cannot be merely hypothetical or informational.

¶360 · ¶2609.6 · ¶2702.2 · ¶303.3See also: , , , , ,
UnconstitutionalUnited Methodist Church

IN RE: Request from the Northeastern Jurisdictional Conference Related to the Authority of the Interjurisdictional Committee on Episcopacy

October 26, 2024 · Northeastern Jurisdictional Conference and Northeastern Jurisdictional Committee on Episcopacy

The Judicial Council ruled that the Interjurisdictional Committee on Episcopacy exceeded its authority by recommending that one bishop serve both the West Virginia area (Northeastern Jurisdiction) and Holston area (Southeastern Jurisdiction), which would violate the bishop allocation limits set by General Conference.

Key Holding

The Interjurisdictional Committee on Episcopacy cannot recommend bishop assignments that exceed the jurisdictional allocation limits established by General Conference.

¶48 · ¶2609.6 · ¶2610 · ¶16See also:
United Methodist Church

Petition for Declaratory Decision from the Alabama-West Florida Annual Conference regarding the meaning, application, and effect of ¶2549 of The Book of Discipline, 2016, as it relates to a policy, process, or method for United Methodist Churches to exit or separate from the denomination

October 26, 2024 · Alabama-West Florida Annual Conference

The Judicial Council ruled that annual conferences cannot use church closure procedures in ¶2549 as a way for local churches to leave the denomination with their property. Only General Conference has authority to create pathways for disaffiliation.

Key Holding

Paragraph 2549 applies to church closure and sale of property, not disaffiliation, and cannot be construed or used as legislation permitting the 'gracious exit' of local churches.

¶2549 · ¶2553 · ¶2501 · ¶425.1 · ¶2610.1 · ¶2549.2 · ¶2549.3 · ¶2549.4 · ¶2540 · ¶2541See also:
No JurisdictionUnited Methodist Church

Motion by Kentucky Annual Conference Requesting a Declaratory Decision on Whether Their Conference Can Utilize ¶2549 or Some Other Provision of the Discipline as a Pathway for the Exit of Local Churches from The United Methodist Church

October 26, 2024 · Kentucky Annual Conference

The Kentucky Annual Conference asked if they could use certain rules in the Book of Discipline to help local churches leave the denomination. The Judicial Council said it doesn't have authority to answer that type of question.

Key Holding

The Judicial Council lacks jurisdiction under ¶2610 to determine whether a given paragraph of the Discipline can be utilized in a certain way or to determine which Discipline paragraph might be used to accomplish a specific goal.

¶2549 · ¶2610See also:
United Methodist Church

IN RE: General Conference petition for a declaratory decision as to meaning, application, and effect of ¶32, Article 1 of the Constitution, and ¶602.4 and ¶602.6 of The Book of Discipline, 2016, regarding the rights of deaconesses to membership, participation, and vote in the Annual Conference

October 26, 2024 · General Conference

The Judicial Council clarified that only 'active' deaconesses have voting rights in Annual Conference, even though some Discipline paragraphs omit the word 'active' when referring to deaconesses.

Key Holding

The constitutional requirement that only 'active' deaconesses have lay membership with voice and vote in annual conference cannot be ignored when interpreting other disciplinary provisions that refer to deaconesses without the 'active' qualifier.

¶32 · ¶602.4 · ¶602.6 · ¶1913 · ¶1913.3a · ¶1913.5 · ¶1913.6 · ¶2610 · ¶16.2See also: ,
United Methodist Church

Request of United Methodist Women, d/b/a United Women in Faith ("UWFaith") for Declaratory Decision Regarding the Meaning, Application, and Effect of ¶¶2512 and 2501 of The Book of Discipline, 2016 of The United Methodist Church in Relation to a Claim of Property Ownership by the Liberia Annual Conference of The United Methodist Church

October 26, 2024 · United Methodist Women, d/b/a United Women in Faith

The Judicial Council stayed a property dispute between United Women in Faith and the Liberia Annual Conference over property in Liberia, waiting for a civil court to first determine ownership. Both parties must follow Discipline provisions regarding property use regardless of who owns the property.

Key Holding

Property ownership disputes must be resolved by civil courts before the Judicial Council can rule on questions about the use and development of church property under the Discipline.

¶2512 · ¶2501 · ¶2610.1 · ¶2610.2c · ¶2506See also: , , , ,
No JurisdictionUnited Methodist Church

Request for Declaratory Decision from the Northeastern Jurisdiction of The United Methodist Church As To Whether An Annual Conference May Create and Adopt a Rule to Determine the Eligibility of a Delegate to Jurisdictional and/or General Conference Who is Actively Serving and/or Providing Leadership in a Denomination Not in Full Communion with The United Methodist Church

October 26, 2024 · Northeastern Jurisdiction of The United Methodist Church

The Judicial Council refused to answer a question about whether annual conferences can make rules about delegate eligibility for people serving in other churches because the request didn't meet proper requirements.

Key Holding

A request for declaratory decision must be germane to regular business of the requesting body, have direct effect on its work, and address specific Discipline paragraphs to establish jurisdiction.

¶2610.1 · ¶2610.2fSee also: ,
United Methodist Church

Use of ¶2549 Related to Petitions to Annual Conference Requesting Church Closure

October 26, 2024 · Alabama-West Florida Annual Conference

The Judicial Council ruled that new provisions allowing Church Councils to petition annual conferences for church closure are unconstitutional because they bypass the proper authority of Charge Conferences.

Key Holding

Constitutional authority of the Charge Conference cannot be delegated to the Church Council, and provisions allowing Church Councils to petition for church closure unconstitutionally usurp Charge Conference authority.

¶2549.2 · ¶2549.3 · ¶244.1 · ¶246.1 · ¶247 · ¶248 · ¶252 · ¶43 · ¶2610See also: , ,
United Methodist Church

General Conference Petition for a Declaratory Decision Concerning the Constitutionality and Application of ¶ 101 as Amended by the Adoption of Calendar Item 283, in Relation to ¶¶ 27 and 31.5 Under Article V of the Constitution, and Specifically Whether Jurisdictions Have the Authority to Adapt The Book of Discipline in the Same Manner as Central Conferences

May 03, 2024 · General Conference (by vote of 492 in favor, 168 opposed)

General Conference asked the Judicial Council to rule on whether jurisdictions now have the same power as central conferences to adapt church law. The request came too late in the conference for a ruling, so it was postponed to fall 2024.

Key Holding

The Judicial Council deferred the constitutional question regarding jurisdictional authority to adapt The Book of Discipline to its Fall 2024 docket due to insufficient time for proper consideration.

¶101 · ¶27 · ¶31.5
United Methodist Church

Petition for Declaratory Decision from the 2024 General Conference to clarify Judicial Council Decision 1501 regarding how ¶407 relates to ¶512.3, and whether a bishop elected in 2022 can be transferred to another jurisdiction in less time than contemplated by Judicial Council Decision 1501

May 3, 2024 · 2024 General Conference

The Judicial Council clarified that bishops must serve one full quadrennium in their electing jurisdiction before being transferred, and that ¶407 only governs initial bishop assignments, not transfers.

Key Holding

Paragraph 49.3 constitutionally restricts bishop transfers until they have served one quadrennium in their electing jurisdiction, and ¶407 only applies to original assignments, not subsequent transfers.

¶49.3 · ¶407 · ¶512.3 · ¶721.2 · ¶2610See also:
United Methodist Church

General Conference Petition for a Declaratory Decision as to Meaning, Application, and Effect of ¶ 32, Article 1 of the Constitution, and ¶ 602.4 and ¶ 602.6 of the 2016 Book of Discipline regarding the rights of Deaconesses to Membership, Participation, and Vote in the Annual Conference

May 03, 2024 · General Conference

The General Conference petitioned for clarity on whether deaconesses have the right to be members of, participate in, and vote at Annual Conference sessions. The Judicial Council deferred this matter to its Fall 2024 docket.

Key Holding

Matter deferred for future consideration - no substantive ruling issued.

¶32 · ¶602.4 · ¶602.6
United Methodist Church

Petition for Declaratory Decision from the 2024 General Conference on the Meaning, Application, and Effect of ¶ 2533 of the 2016 Book of Discipline Concerning the Right of the Board of Trustees of a Local Church to Adopt Policies Prohibiting the Conduct of Same-Sex Marriage Ceremonies

May 03, 2024 · 2024 General Conference

The Judicial Council ruled that local church boards of trustees can adopt policies prohibiting same-sex marriage ceremonies on church property without violating disciplinary provisions about pastoral use of property.

Key Holding

Local church boards of trustees have the authority to adopt policies prohibiting same-sex marriage ceremonies despite paragraph 2533's provisions protecting pastoral use of church property.

¶2533 · ¶2610 · ¶2544
United Methodist Church

Petition for Declaratory Decision from the 2024 General Conference on the Meaning, Application, and Effect of ¶ 512 of the 2016 Book of Discipline Concerning the Authority of the Interjurisdictional Committee on Episcopacy to Recommend the Number of Bishops in the Jurisdictions

May 03, 2024 · 2024 General Conference

The Judicial Council ruled that the Interjurisdictional Committee on Episcopacy has authority to recommend the number of bishops in all jurisdictions based on newly amended paragraph 404.2.

Key Holding

Under the newly amended and effective ¶ 404.2, the Interjurisdictional Committee on Episcopacy has the authority to recommend to the General Conference the number of bishops in all jurisdictions, provided it follows the process set forth in said provision.

¶404.2 · ¶512 · ¶2610
United Methodist Church

IN RE: Petition for Declaratory Decision from the 2024 General Conference on the meaning, application, and effect of ¶49.3 of the Book of Discipline

May 03, 2024 · 2024 General Conference

The Judicial Council clarified that bishops must serve a full four-year term (quadrennium) in their electing jurisdiction before becoming eligible for transfer to another jurisdiction.

Key Holding

Bishops elected less than two years ago are not eligible for transfer under ¶49.3 because they have not served one full quadrennium as required.

¶49.3 · ¶721.2 · ¶2610
United Methodist Church

Petition for Declaratory Decision from the 2024 General Conference on the Constitutionality of Petition 21040 and Petition 21039 of the Regionalization Plan Concerning the Creation and Organization of Regional Conferences

May 03, 2024 · 2024 General Conference

The Judicial Council ruled it cannot review proposed constitutional amendments about Regional Conferences because they haven't been ratified yet. The Council can only review legislation that doesn't require constitutional changes.

Key Holding

The Judicial Council lacks jurisdiction to review proposed constitutional amendments or disciplinary changes that require ratification of constitutional amendments.

¶2610 · ¶2609.2 · ¶543.7See also:
UnconstitutionalUnited Methodist Church

IN RE: Petition for Declaratory Decision from the General Conference 2024 Regarding the Constitutionality, Meaning, Application, and Effect of Petition 20299 (Amended ¶ 409)

May 2, 2024 · Delegate from the New England Annual Conference requesting declaratory decision on behalf of General Conference 2024

The Judicial Council ruled that retired bishops must have their travel expenses paid to attend Council of Bishops meetings, striking down a General Conference petition that would have made retired bishops pay their own way.

Key Holding

All bishops of The United Methodist Church, both active and retired, are constitutionally entitled to attend Council of Bishops meetings with expenses paid under ¶ 47 of the Constitution.

¶47 · ¶2610See also:
United Methodist Church

Petition for Declaratory Decision from the General Conference 2024 Regarding the Meaning, Application, and Effect of ¶¶ 408.1b and 357.1 of The 2016 Book of Discipline Concerning Mandatory Retirement of Bishops

May 02, 2024 · Delegate from the Liberia Annual Conference

The Judicial Council clarified that mandatory retirement rules for elders don't apply to bishops, and that Central Conference bishops must retire under the 2012 rules within one year of General Conference if they meet age requirements.

Key Holding

Paragraph 357.1 mandatory retirement provisions apply to ordained elders but not to bishops, and Central Conference bishops retire under ¶ 408.1b of the 2012 Discipline.

¶408.1b · ¶357.1 · ¶2601.1 · ¶2610 · ¶2201.2See also:
United Methodist Church

Petition for Declaratory Decision from the General Conference 2024 Regarding the Meaning, Application, and Effect of ¶ 511.1 of The 2016 Book of Discipline Concerning Youth Representation on the Commission on the General Conference

April 29, 2024 · Delegate from the Upper New York Annual Conference

The Judicial Council ruled that the General Conference must find and elect at least one youth to serve on the Commission on the General Conference, even if no youth delegates were elected to General Conference.

Key Holding

The General Conference is required to identify, nominate, and elect at least one youth to the Commission on the General Conference when no youth representation exists among the members.

¶511.1 · ¶2610
United Methodist Church

Petition for Declaratory Decision Regarding Paragraph 710.4 of the 2016 Book of Discipline

April 22, 2024 · Council of Bishops

The Judicial Council ruled that general agency members elected in 2016 can serve a second term if re-elected in 2024, treating their extended 8-year service as one quadrennium due to the delayed General Conference.

Key Holding

General agency members elected in 2016 are still serving their first four-year term despite eight years of service, making them eligible for a second term if re-elected in 2024.

¶710.4 · ¶2010.2b · ¶2608.2 · ¶16See also: , , , , ,